Baltimore City Paper home page.

LOG IN | Not a user? Create Account

Television

Bi Sci-Fi

BBC's Gleefully Bonkers Torchwood Returns Born-Again Queer Hard For Its Second Season

Daniel Krall
Email this Story Print-ready version leave a comment

By Ian Grey | Posted 3/26/2008

The 2006 first season of BBC America's Torchwood was the most singularly vexing tease of a televisual sci-fi experience a geek could imagine. For every strange delight--the show's instantly identifiable gritty/glossy digital noir look, queered Hawksian banter, sudden-death romance, and fevered willingness to insert sex into everything, typified by an episode about an alien who feeds off orgasms--there was an equal negative. The worst offenders: a reliance on 11th-hour high-tech deux ex machinas and an increasingly Lost-like sense that the show's creators were just making shit up as they went along.

But with the second season, currently airing Saturday nights on BBC America, Torchwood's bi-sci-fi geek promise of being a randy mix of Queer as Folk and Doctor Who--creator Russell T. Davies respectively created/reanimated both shows--is seriously fulfilled, thanks to the appropriation of one actor from Buffy, the Vampire Slayer and a generous infusion of tropes from Joss Whedon's classic.

Still, with the good chance that you've neither seen nor heard of Torchwood, some exposition. Torchwood is a secret group operating "outside the government, beyond the police" so as to staunch the flow of aliens, ghosts, Romans, the black plague, and sundry other inter-temporal flotsam slipping into our world through the Rift--a space-time anomaly in Cardiff, Wales. Working from an underground lair done up in retro tubeway chic, complete with mortuary and in-house pet pterodactyl, Torchwood is composed of plucky local cop Gwen (Eve Myles), laddish cynic physician Owen (Burn Gorman), IT girl Toshiko (Naoko Mori), and fashion-conscious teaboy (!) Ianto (Gareth David-Lloyd). All are under the command of the ever-grinning, mysterious, possibly immortal American Capt. Jack Harkness (John Barrowman).

Unfortunately, the first season strained to define its themes and characters with sufficient velocity to prevent U.K. viewers from switching to Heroes' vanilla recombinant pulp, often devolving into an alien-of-the-week format dashed with tantalizing bits of identity politics. What kept fans tuning in was the promise of the Torchwood crew and Capt. Jack, who was kind of great from Day 1. A sexually omnivorous, fine-jawed scamp in a 1940s military long coat, Barrowman plays him like a camp Tom Cruise, alternately/simultaneously arrogant, pigheaded, flirty, world-weary, and idealistic. But in the first season's fantastic finale, Jack morphed from lovable rogue into an entirely new genre archetype.

Due to a time-machine gaffe by Owen, an inter-temporal, life-absorbing God--"The Great Destroyer," no less--threatens life on Earth. With the chips down, Jack's browbeating and flirtatiousness dissolve to reveal an absolute, almost fatherly love of his co-workers. He forgives Owen and sacrifices his own immortal self--seemingly for keeps this time--to slay the opposition. One acolyte--excuse us, Gwen--waits at his side for days until Jack rises briefly before disappearing, presumably to allow his followers to follow his example and continue his good works.

Needless to say, it's cheeky to blatantly reposition your horny gay-leaning hero as a Christ substitute, a deliriously fun conceit that prefaced the high learning curve seen in the second season's opener, an episode aptly titled "Kiss, Kiss, Bang, Bang." It opens with the chase for a coke-snorting alien blowfish--seriously--and the cheerfully unexplained return of Jack, before segueing to time traveler Capt. John (James Marsters, aka Spike from Buffy), who swaggers out of the Rift done up in Adam Ant pirate-punk gear, paralyzing lip gloss, and a horny leer to the accompaniment of Ennio Morricone-esque audio camp.

Captains John and Jack meet in a sleazy bar, make out like demons, beat the crap out of each other, share a drink, and then bitch about each other's wrinkles. If you'd never seen the show, you could be forgiven for thinking your TV went completely insane. Turns out, John is Jack's dark doppelgänger/ex-lover gone gleefully bad and willing to fuck and/or kill every member of Torchwood in order to--well, no spoilage here.

Marsters' appearance is both a reminder of just how much Torchwood already owes Buffy--for obvious instance, the alien-spewing Rift is a sci-fi take on Buffy's demon-spewing Hellmouth-- and a preview of just how smartly it would appropriate from Whedon's world, which, in a weird/wonderful bit of intertextual alchemy, has allowed Davies' show to become more indelibly, well, Torchwood-like. Like Buffy herself, Gwen struggles to keep her life as a normal person and world saver separate. Toshiko has expanded from a dangerously archetypical "Asian"--all cool competence and raised Spock brows--into Torchwood's Willow surrogate, the show's supercute, smart, intrinsically open-souled center.%uFFFD

But geeky citations aside, what Torchwood most effectively assimilates from Whedon are supernatural nasties who function as metaphors for the characters' inner demons, along with a sweetly humanistic wallow in the gang's existential big pains. In that way that renders the science fictional literary, Jack's horrifically traumatic youth is revealed; his response to it explains why he needs to help people. A parallel-universe episode offers the anxious, socially inept Owen hiding under his semi-douchebag skin. And Toshiko finally meets a man she can love--a WWI soldier suffering from PTSD--but her painful duty to the greater good trumps romances, and so much for that.

And so fused in a cauldron of its characters' essential loneliness, the Torchwood crew, as in most great TV, coheres into a alternative viable family. Beyond that, the current season shows that beneath its bisexual snogs and smart quips, Torchwood is about difference, empathy, and striving to do the right thing in an indifferent world while knowing you'll inevitably getting it wrong half the time and learning to forgive yourself for doing so. And so Torchwood now isn't just delightful; it's kind of essential, inspirational even.

Related stories

Television archives

More Stories

Teaser Trailer for David Simon's Treme Debuts (1/12/2010)

The Ken Burns Effect (12/15/2009)

Baltimore School for the Arts alumnus cut from So You Think You Can Dance (7/10/2009)

More from Ian Grey

The Perfect Prescription (4/22/2009)
A musician explores the role music has played in treating his mental illness

Teen Screams (9/24/2008)
Dark Young Adult Fiction Captures Rudderless Horrors of Contemporary Adolescence

Dr. Horrible: Triumphant (7/21/2008)

Leave a comment

billaalto

1 comments.

Member since 3/26/2008

Excellent review. In spite of its rift-wide imperfections, Torchwood remains what it's been from ep.1 series 1, the existential motherlode - which is to say I'm probably one of an infintessimal minority who actually liked the bleak tide of S1 as much (even more?!) than the glorious high campery/objectively more satisfying S2.

Report this comment Posted 3.26.2008 5:32 AM

hypnotoad911

1 comments.

Member since 3/26/2008

Some SERIOUS errors here.

It wasn't a TIME MACHINE Owen messed with it was the RIFT MANIPULATOR

BIG difference.

The "parallel universe " was actually altered memories

And I REALLY wish folks would stop comparing John Barrowman to "VOMIT BOY" tom cruise they are NOTHING alike - for one thing Barrowman has TALENT! He can act, sing and he's Damned gorgeous! tom cruise is just disgusting

Report this comment Posted 3.26.2008 1:59 PM

phoenix53

1 comments.

Member since 3/28/2008

Barrowman is a name that will survive for decades - he is that good. Torchwood is a can't-wait-for-the-next-episode knockout. Too much analysis can really be a downer, you know? The show is edgy, sexy, and just plain fun. Stop trying to turn it into a Freudian victim!

Report this comment Posted 3.28.2008 9:08 PM

Brummie_B-more

1 comments.

Member since 4/1/2008

Umm, Barrowman will definitly not be around for decades, unless doing street theatre counts. The guy is practically reading his lines off of a cue card in the show.He has no talent and very litle ability to actually develop his character outside of a wannabe tough guy American cop.

I know you Yanks love British TV and think all of it is a masterpiece, but Torchwood is terrible. Its a cross between Buffy and X-files with all the trite from Dr Who. Every reputable critic in the UK hates it and cannot wait for Barrowman to crawl back in the hole he came from.

In his spare time Barrowman does children's theatre, ( His last role was Aladdin and he has Peter Pan in his sights!) so I do not forsee him lasting for much longer in the real world of acting.

Report this comment Posted 4.1.2008 11:42 AM

Comment on this article

If you are a Citypaper.com member, please enter your username and password.
If you don't want to join our site right now, click the GUESTS tab.

User:

Password:

 

Don't have an account? Sign up now.
Already have an account? Log in now.

Choose a display name

Your email address:

 

Events

Restaurants

Bars+Clubs

Local Music

HIPPIES WITH THE FLOW: No experience necessary

NORTH AMERICAN TRADE SCHOOLS:

GET CONNECTED WITH A NEW CAREER: All-State Career

MEDIX SCHOOL: Massage therapy and more!

View all TOP JOB ads

FELLS POINT: APT. 4 RENT

CHARLES VILLAGE-21218 : The Baltimorean Apartments

View all TOP RENTAL ads

> PLACE CLASSIFIED AD

 

 

Privacy Statement