Baltimore City Paper home page.

LOG IN | Not a user? Create Account

The News Hole

Victim Mentality

Email this Story Print-ready version leave a comment

By Edward Ericson Jr. | Posted 7/30/2008

The Sun's front page today is dominated by a photograph of a foreclosure "victim." Veronica Peterson is about to be thrown out of a home she bought in November 2006 with two loans totaling $545,000.

The story is about the mortgage bailout plan signed this morning by President Bush, but the new rules--which will go into effect in October--are too late to help "hundreds of thousands" of "struggling homeowners" like Peterson, The Sun observes: "The 45-year-old single mother of three and home day care operator couldn't keep up with her mortgage payments, based on adjustable interest rates of 8 1/4 and 11 1/4 percent." Her eviction notice coming any day now, Peterson doesn't "know when I'm going, I don't know where I'm going," she told the Sun.

But in the comments section below the article, hundreds of readers pointed out what the Sun's reporters and editors could not, apparently: that Peterson had no business in that house, and that she's lived there for more than a year rent- and mortgage-free. "Where do you think we can get in on this deal?" one commenter, calling himself Henry Bowman, asked another.

The online court and land records show that Peterson closed on the house on Nov. 3, 2006, with two loans from Washington Mutual. The main mortgage, for $436,000, had a starting interest rate of 8.5 percent, adjusting in December of this year to the London Interbank Offered Rate plus 4.99 percent. The second loan, often called a "piggyback," totaled $109,000 with an interest rate of 11.25 percent, according to The Sun.

Those two payments together would have totaled $3,386.17 per month. That's before property taxes, upkeep, utilities, etc. Peterson would have to earn at least $50,000 per year just to make her house payments.

But it appears that Peterson made few--if any--payments. The foreclosure was filed July 31, 2007. The balance on the main note then was $435,735.86, plus unpaid interest accrued from Jan. 1, 2007, plus $1,005.72 in late charges. This suggests that Peterson made, at most, one payment on her house: the December, 2006 payment. Given the grace periods typical in home-mortgage business, it is at least as likely that her first payment was not due until January 2007, which would mean she has made zero payments.

Had she made all of her payments, Peterson would have spent about $64,335 so far. Had she rented a similar place, she would have been charged around $2,500 per month--a total of $47,500--since January 2007. Instead, she apparently paid nothing.

"This bill doesn't do anything for the people who have lost their homes or are in the process of losing their homes," Peterson said, according to The Sun. "All the laws passed have been basically to help the lending institutions."

But if Peterson has been living in a $500,000 house (or, let's be honest, but for the real-estate bubble, it was probably never more than a $350,000 house) rent- and mortgage-free since January 2007, how much of a victim is she? And how much of a villain is Washington Mutual and its bond holders?

The Sun is right about this: There are many thousands of people like Veronica Peterson out there, and thousands of others who are losing not one, but sometimes three or more houses to foreclosure. The Sun and other media outlets should describe them with a word or phrase more accurate than "struggling homeowners."

Email Edward Ericson Jr.

Read more

The News Hole archives

More Money Stories

An Old Skool Banking Idea (2/4/2010)
an old school banking proposal at the Times

Fannie-Freddie Updates (4/22/2009)

AIG Update (3/17/2009)

More from Edward Ericson Jr.

An Old Skool Banking Idea (2/4/2010)
an old school banking proposal at the Times

Councilmania (2/4/2010)
Keeping tabs on the City Council's activities so you don't have to

More Apartments, Less Parking, but 1621 Bank St. Is Not to Be Demolished (2/3/2010)
update: More Apartments, Less Parking, but 1621 Bank St. is Not to be Demolished

Related by keywords

FHA Default Rates Near 10 Percent in Crash Course 2/2/2010

Former Housing Commissioner's Redevelopment Project Spitting Bricks in The News Hole 2/1/2010

in The News Hole 2/1/2010

Securitization's First Wave of Failures in Crash Course 1/29/2010

Collapse: 2200 Bryant Ave. in The News Hole 1/25/2010

Bmore Publisher Pitched Proposal for Taxpayer Funding in The News Hole 1/19/2010

Online Pub Bmore Appears on Board of Estimates Agenda in The News Hole 1/13/2010

Journalism Study Focuses on Baltimore in The News Hole 1/11/2010

Mum's the Word on New Remington Development in The News Hole 1/8/2010

Judge Dismisses City's Suit Against Wells Fargo in Crash Course 1/7/2010

Tags: mortgage, media, The Sun, Housing, Development

Leave a comment

Marshall

8 comments.

Member since 11/19/2007

I tired of being told I should feel bad for people who "bought" over-inflated real estate and then can't pay the bill. Boo freakin' hoo.

Report this comment Posted 7.30.2008 4:53 PM

B Smarter

6 comments.

Member since 5/7/2008

Let's face it...we all know the Sun is a rag. Thank you for giving me the real story, City Paper.

We can thank all of the Veronica Petersons of the world for dragging down the housing market. Cry me a freaking river.

Report this comment Posted 7.30.2008 8:33 PM

baltimark

4 comments.

Member since 2/28/2007

She's not dragging down the housing market. She's the reason house prices got to where they were. It's just falling back to where it should be.

Report this comment Posted 7.30.2008 10:28 PM

Comment on this article

If you are a Citypaper.com member, please enter your username and password.
If you don't want to join our site right now, click the GUESTS tab.

User:

Password:

 

Don't have an account? Sign up now.
Already have an account? Log in now.

Choose a display name

Your email address:

 

Events

Restaurants

Bars+Clubs

Local Music

TECH EXPO CAREER FAIR: Tues., Feb. 9th

NORTH AMERICAN TRADE SCHOOLS:

TESST COLLEGE OF TECHNOLOGY: Train for a career!

MD WORKFORCE EXCHANGE: Looking for a job?

View all TOP JOB ads

CHARLES VILLAGE-21218 : The Baltimorean Apartments

FELLS POINT: APT. 4 RENT

View all TOP RENTAL ads

> PLACE CLASSIFIED AD

 

 

Privacy Statement